PilgrimNotWanderer

Mar 2

Total Failure

Sure, alleged Toronto #g20 police misconduct needs to be addressed, but this brouhaha distracts protesters from the sad fact of their total failure. They’ll continue to focus on Police misconduct b/c it plays better than the message of the actual protest & gives meaning to their lives. And that’s the whole point of that sort of lefty protest, no? Police misconduct was the perfect gift.

Meanwhile who’s talking about the message of their protest?


Feb 10

Science v. Philosophy

How is science rightly done? What if even good and proper science ain’t knowledge?

How shall we inquire into this? 

We shall head down the way of philosophy.

In this way, we see philosophy’s preeminence over science.

Actually, even now, as we reflect on how to proceed, we are already doing philosophy. In this way, we see philosophy is no soft option — it’s the heavy burden borne by the curious in and through their curiosity. 

Someone will say, “No, instead we shall scientifically study science. After all, science and knowledge are coextensive.”

And I will respond, “Shall we? Are they?” 

Someone will say, “You’re too curious for your own good.”

And I will respond, “Am I?”


God and Explanation (V)

  • Someone will say: We've as much evidence for God as we have for a teapot orbiting mars -- which is to say none.
  • And I will respond: Actually, from the existence of any teapot whatsoever we can see for sure that we live in God's world.

Gillespie

Gillespie


Feb 5

God and Explanation (IV)

  • Someone will say: What's the evidence for God?
  • And I will respond: So much depends on what it is that we mean by God, no?
  • Let's consider that teapot right here on the table; never mind the matter of teapots in orbit. That teapot right here will be enough. And now we procede.

God and Explanation (III)

  • Someone will say: Either God is an explanatory postulate, or belief in God is mere superstition.
  • And I will respond: What of metaphysical knowledge? What of philosophy?


Jan 29
It brews. Now best called a bricolage?

It brews. Now best called a bricolage?


God and Explanation (II)

  • Someone will say: Either God is an explanatory postulate, or belief in God is mere superstition.
  • God is not a *successful* explanatory postulate, so God is either a failed hypothesis or belief in God is mere superstition.
  • Pick your poison.
  • I will respond: You're going to have to do better than this. Give me some reason to think this is so.

The Devil and Daniel Johnston


Page 1 of 2